The Elusive Kitten: Follow-Up (Deacon Robert Peckham)

By -
 An unexpected postscript…- - -
It seems like the folk art paintings I research tend to recur again and again with alarming frequency. I'll write to a friend about an artwork I've come across, and hear "I was at that auction" or "I own that painting" or "I saw that portrait last week”! This happens so often that you'd think there's only a few dozen folk art paintings in the whole world. Except for the ones I'm trying to find, like Oliver Ellis Adams, which I expect will turn up 100 years from now in Antarctica.
After posting my article about another mysterious Peckham child in blue — “Girl and Cat" — I shared it with American folk art expert and dealer David Schorsch, who's wisely advised me before on my Peckham research. And, to my astonishment, he replied as follows:
My mother and I owned girl in blue w grey cat before it sold at Sothebys. It was originally found in Massachusetts. We purchased it from Sam Herrup. We were again the buyers the last time it auctioned and sold it to private clients in 2017.  It is pictured in our advertisement in the Magazine Antiques, November 1981, p. 1049. 
I couldn’t believe it! What are the odds? Higher than you’d think, given the Schorschs’ good taste in artwork. David and his assistant Cory Bowie generously sent me a high-res photograph of the girl and her kitten, which I’ve secured permission to share here. It’s a treat to finally see this wonderful work in such close detail. 
(Credit: Private collection, photo courtesy of David A. Schorsch and Eileen M. Smiles, Woodbury, CT; photograph by Richard Goodbody.)
They’re still plotting something.
I also asked David to share that 1981 TMA ad from David & Marjorie Schorsch, Inc, which he graciously provided:
Endearingly, it reads: “A delightful American folk portrait, depicting a little girl holding her gray cat, about 1835. Found in Massachusetts.” 
The Massachusetts origin is certainly a point in favor towards the Peckham-ness. David didn’t specify where this painting received its subsequent Peckham attribution, nor who or when — presumably sometime between 1981 and 1983, when it arrived at the Sotheby’s auction. It’s important to remember that Peckham literature was scarce at the time, compared to the modern abundance of information. So much so, in fact, that in 1978, the good Deacon was still known as the nameless “Raymond Limner.”

(Ironically, this eerie and compelling group portrait feels unlikely as a Peckham attribution, at least without a color photo, though it clearly comes from a very talented hand. The little-known Orlando Bears is a possibility, but hardly a guarantee; I know of no Bears paintings on panel. That said, another Frick Art Reference Library entry mistakes a blindingly obvious Bears for a Peckham. Bears was equally gifted with his ability to capture young people and detailed interiors. More research is forthcoming.
EDIT: David Schorsch weighed in on this "Raymond Limner" picture - he says "Raymond Limner at Hirschl and Adler was later re attributed by them to Peckham, is most like Bears." The odds are certainly in Bears's favor.)
Over the next decades, Peckham scholarship accumulated steadily, but slowly. In 1979, Dale Johnson, a researcher at The Met’s American Art division, published “Delineator of the Human Face Divine” in the American Art Journal. She introduced the talented folk artist on a broader scale with comprehensive and compelling attributions. The next major Peckham publication appeared in 1985 in the January Maine Antiques Digest. Folk collector David Krashes wrote the thoroughly informative “Robert Peckham, Portrait Painter of Massachusetts,” adding a new selection of portraits to the collective knowledge. Here, on the last page, we can find another record of “Girl with Cat,” aka “Young Girl Holding a Kitten,” describing its smashing success at auction ($15,000!):
Krashes also enticingly mentions several more private-collection Peckhams out there in the wild, just waiting to be found. Stay tuned.

Popular posts from this blog

Old Finds: A Nantucket Legacy (James S. Hathaway)

By -
Image
Folk art is fraught with loss. One of the best-known artists, Joseph Whiting Stock, recorded 900 paintings in his lifetime, but only 100 still survive . It is quite possible that this statistic applies to every folk artist we know, prompting the grim realization that only a slim fraction of these major and minor masterpieces are still intact at all. The same may be true for folk artists themselves. For every single one we have identified, there might be another whose name we’ll never know. And even among the artists who have survived — the lucky ones by name, the unlucky ones as a “limner” — a large number of them have slipped through the cracks. I’d like to help bring them back.  Our first is James S. Hathaway.  I first saw these while scrolling an endless search of Frick Digital Collections, using the magnificently unsophisticated approach of looking at a lot of pictures and hoping something will stick. This one made me stop and stare. It’s James S. Hathaway’s striking repre...
READ MORE »

The Elusive Kitten: How To Spot A Peckham (Deacon Robert Peckham)

By -
Image
In which a cat is very hard to find, because art imitates life. It may not come as a surprise that my recent interest in the works of folk portraitist Deacon Robert Peckham has led me to compile a full catalog of known and unknown Peckhams. After all, when one discovers a new favorite artist, it’s a natural instinct to gather together all of their works, arrange them in proper detailed order, and then go find some more. Fortunately, the job’s much easier when the artist is consistent. So far, during the Peckham-scavenging process, I’ve spotted about a half-dozen of them. They’re usually not too difficult to track down. However (at risk of sounding like the Wicked Witch of the West) this little girl and her little cat escaped me for months. 
READ MORE »

The Haunted Nephew (Deacon Robert Peckham)

By -
Image
In which a terrifying little boy goes missing, but winds up immortalized in a classic horror movie. The process of compiling an artist’s works is never easy. Especially in folk art, unsigned pieces are often scattered far and wide, identified only by stylistic quirks and a tenuous chain of linked names and family connections. So, for the sake of thoroughness, whenever I’m tracking down an artist, I scrounge around as many sites as I can get my hands on. You never know what might turn up.
READ MORE »

Eminently Artful? (Deacon Robert Peckham)

By -
Image
The art of resemblance is a tricky one. People don’t like being committed to memory in an unflattering likeness (just ask any photographer). Historically, artists often chose to enhance a person’s appearance, smoothing out any blemishes and modifying their features for the better. Most frequently, portraits aspired towards whatever the contemporary ideal of conventional beauty happened to be, which varied widely over time and culture. However, the underlying principle is the same: Don’t make them look bad.
READ MORE »

Meet the Gages (Deacon Robert Peckham)

By -
Image
From a typo to a temporary loss of identity. A large part of my folk art research method involves scrolling through thousands of records of American School sales, looking at countless pictures to match patterns and spot similarities. There’s a method to the madness, even though most of the time, it is just madness. But when something leaps out, it makes it all worthwhile. One example of the illogical soundness of the brute-force search is Frances and Humphrey Cousens — Peckham’s last two paintings, as listed in Deborah Chotner's Hobby Horse catalog (p. 43), aka the Peckham bible. 
READ MORE »